- Home
- About
- Documentary Printed Precancels
- The Fullerton List
- NYSE Brokers 1898-1902 A thru K
- NYSE Brokers 1898 - 1902 L thru Z
- Insurance Agents
- Insurance Companies
- CBOT
- Railroads
- On-document Uses with Frank Sente
- Revenue Stamped Paper with Bob Hohertz
- On Beyond Holcombe with Malcolm Goldstein
- Graded Stamps
Sunday, March 12, 2023
Saturday, March 4, 2023
Germania Half Dollar Savings Bank, Wheeling, West Virginia
Sunday, February 26, 2023
1898 Documentary Perfin Cancels
- P & Company (possibly Pearl & Co.)
- FB... (possibly Finley Barrell & Co. or several others)
- AN & Company
- Price, McCormick & Company
- Ladenburg, Thalmann Company
- Edward Sweet & Company
- DeCoppett & Company
- DeCoppett & Doremus
- Lazard Freres
- P. J. Goodhart & Company
Insurance company perfins:
- New York Life Insurance Company
- Metropolitan Life Insurance Company
For the purpose of this article and in general, perfins do not include punch cancel initials or large punch outs, shaped or not. These types of cancels will be featured in a comprehensive post in the coming weeks. This post will also not cover generic perfins like those that spell out Cancelled or Paid, include only numbers, or are shapes.
The first example, and the most complex type of perfin on the 1898s, is that shown at the top of this post. The cancel remains unidentified but possibly comes from the New York Stock Exchange firm Pearl & Company.
Edward Sweet & Company
Saturday, February 11, 2023
Cotton Brokers: Mohr, Hanemann & Company
New York Times, June 22, 1918:
Sunday, January 22, 2023
"Stacked" Use of R184s on a Stock Sale Memorandum
Stamp washing and reuse was somewhat common on the 1898 dollar values, prompting ink experimentation that would help prevent effective cancel washing, and rules regarding stamp cancellation that required not only ink cancellation but mutilation through cuts or punch-outs.
By late 1899, cancel washing and stamp reuse had become so common that the Commissioner of Internal Revenue made it mandatory for all revenue stamps of 10 cents or more be mutilated by three parallel cuts into the stamp. So from January 1900, many of the dollar denominated revenue stamps are found with cut cancels. The regulation seems to have been mostly ignored for the documentary battleships.
Today is featured 8 $1 stamps that have been appropriately cut cancelled. However, they have been stacked on a stock sale memorandum. While the regulations regarding cancelling don't address stacking the stamps this way, I do not believe this way of applying the stamps to the document would have been approved by revenue agents.
A Malcom & Coombe sale memorandum to Eames & Moore for 400 shares of Southern Railway requiring $8 of revenue stamps:
A review of section six of the earler 1898 war revenue law makes no mention of a prohibition of stacking stamps before cancelling them. However, the law does say:
That in any and all cases where an adhesive stamp shall be used for denoting any tax imposed by this Act, except as hereinafter provided, the person using or affixing the same shall write or stamp thereupon the initials of his name and the date upon wich the same shall be attached or used...
It seems to me that it is implicit that in order for the above to be enforced, all the stamps on the document must be visible. At least in this sense the stacking on the Malcom & Coombe memo is not permitted.
Certainly, stacking wasn't necessary to fit all the stamps on the memo of sale. Here are two examples of extensive real estate use on stock sale memos:
Thursday, January 19, 2023
W. S. Keyser & Company, Timber and Lumber Exporters
Tuesday, January 10, 2023
Bill of Exchange Fragments: Illinois Trust & Savings Bank and the Story of the Wingfoot Air Express Crash
The Illinois Trust and Savings Bank pioneered the establishment of the trust business in Chicago and the midwest, and became one of America's largest financial institutions in the early 20th century. They also built a grand main bank building at the corner of Jackson and La Salle in Chicago, pictured on the postcard below:




















































